Imagine financing a $35,000 car, only to have it totaled a year later when it’s worth $28,000. Without gap insurance, you could be responsible for the $7,000 difference out of pocket. That’s where gap insurance comes in, bridging the gap between your car’s actual cash value (ACV) and your outstanding loan.
So, how much is gap insurance? On average, it costs $20-$100 per year if purchased from an insurer, or $400-$700 from a dealership. For most drivers, buying from the insurance company is far cheaper, potentially saving hundreds.
Over 80% of new car buyers finance their vehicles, which makes gap insurance a crucial consideration. In this guide, we’ll break down the pricing by provider, state, and loan type. We’ll also explain where to buy gap insurance, how to save money, and when it’s truly necessary. By the end, you’ll know exactly how much gap insurance should cost and how to get the best deal.
Quick Answer: Gap Insurance Cost at a Glance
Three Pricing Tiers
Auto Insurance Companies
$20-$100/year ($2-$8/month). Average: $88/year. This is the most affordable and recommended option for most drivers.
Dealerships or Lenders
$400-$700 flat fee, sometimes rolling into your loan with interest. High-end dealerships can charge up to $1,500. Total cost, including interest, may exceed $800.
Standalone Providers
$200-$300 flat fee. These fall between insurer and dealership pricing, but availability is limited.
The Cost Difference Reality
Buying from a dealer often costs 100-250% more than going through your insurer. For example, a $600 dealer gap insurance financed at 6% APR over five years totals $680, compared to just $100 through an insurance company. That’s a savings of $580 over the life of the loan.
Why Such a Big Price Gap?
Dealers mark up premiums for convenience, while financing adds interest. Insurance company pricing is transparent and avoids unnecessary profit margins, making it the smarter choice.
Gap Insurance Cost by Provider
Major Insurance Companies – Annual Costs
| Provider | Average Annual Cost | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Progressive | ~$48 ($4/month) | Covers up to 25% of ACV, available in 48 states |
| State Farm | ~$48 ($4/month) | “Payoff Protector” for financed vehicles |
| Nationwide | $50-$60 | Requires deductible; vehicles ≤6 years old |
| Allstate | $10-$50 | Covers up to $50,000 loan difference; up to $1,000 deductible coverage |
| GEICO | $20-$40 | Standard gap requires full coverage |
| USAA | $10-$50 | “Car Replacement Assistance” is only for military members |
| Auto-Owners | ~$60 | Regional availability |
| Erie | $60-$240 | Available in 12 states |
| Travelers | ~$36 | Available in 41 states |
Credit Union Options
Credit union options for gap insurance often provide a more affordable alternative to dealership pricing. For example, AAA charges a flat fee ranging from $299 to $399, depending on regional variations, while local credit unions typically offer coverage for $200 to $400 as a one-time payment, which is often cheaper than what dealerships charge.
Dealership and Lender Costs
$400-$700 standard, up to $1,500 at high-end dealerships. Often marketed as $8-$10/month, hiding the total cost. Interest adds $60-$100 over the loan term.
Gap Insurance Cost by State
Lowest Cost States
In the lowest-cost states, gap insurance is very affordable. West Virginia averages between $40 and $50, while Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont offer coverage for $36 to $48, or about $3–$4 per month. Ohio has some of the cheapest rates at $19 to $30, and Pennsylvania ranges from $21 to $35, making these states ideal for budget-conscious drivers seeking gap protection.
Highest Cost States
In certain states, gap insurance costs can vary widely. Montana sees some of the highest premiums, ranging from $210 to $240, while Colorado can be even higher, between $200 and $393. In Nevada and Florida, gap insurance is much more affordable, averaging $60 to $84, or roughly $5–$7 per month. Meanwhile, Michigan and Louisiana typically have premiums in the $90 to $120 range, illustrating how location and state regulations influence coverage costs.
Mid-Range States
In mid-range states, the cost of gap insurance varies but generally falls within a moderate price range. For example, California averages around $94, Texas about $70, and New York ranges from $80 to $100. Illinois typically sees premiums between $75 and $90, while Georgia averages $60 to $80, reflecting regional differences in vehicle values, loan terms, and insurance practices.
Why Costs Vary
State regulations, accident and theft rates, urban vs. rural markets, and overall insurance costs influence premiums.
State-Specific Regulations
California: Lenders cannot require gap insurance, and a 2023 law introduced oversight on pricing and sales practices.
Factors That Affect Gap Insurance Cost
Vehicle-Related Factors
Vehicle-related factors directly affect gap insurance premiums. The price and value of the car play a major role, with more expensive vehicles costing more to insure. A fast depreciation rate also increases the cost, as the loan balance can quickly exceed the vehicle’s value. Additionally, most insurers limit gap coverage to vehicles under 3–5 years old, so older cars may not qualify for this protection.
Loan-Related Factors
Loan-related factors play a significant role in determining gap insurance costs. A higher loan amount typically results in higher premiums, while a down payment of less than 20% also increases the cost. Longer loan terms can raise premiums by 10–20%, and a higher interest rate slows the build-up of equity in the vehicle, indirectly increasing the insurer’s risk and, therefore, the price of coverage.
Driver-Related Factors
Driver-related factors have a major impact on gap insurance premiums. Younger drivers, especially 18-year-olds, typically pay significantly more than older, more experienced drivers. A poor credit score can increase premiums by 18–22%, while a history of at-fault accidents can raise costs by as much as 42%, reflecting the increased risk perceived by insurers.
Coverage-Related Factors
Coverage-related factors can significantly influence the cost of gap insurance. The type of gap product matters, as enhanced policies that offer additional protection typically cost 10–20% more. Coverage limits also play a role—policies with capped payouts are usually cheaper, while unlimited coverage increases the premium. Additionally, bundling gap insurance with your existing auto policy can often save 5–10% on the total cost.
Where to Buy Gap Insurance: Complete Comparison
Auto Insurance Companies (Recommended)
Auto insurance companies are the most recommended source for gap insurance because coverage is generally cheaper, transparent, and easy to add to your existing policy. Many insurers also allow you to cancel at any time, providing flexibility as your loan balance changes. The main drawbacks are that you must have full coverage on your vehicle, and not all insurance companies offer gap insurance.
Car Dealerships
Car dealerships offer the convenience of purchasing gap insurance at the same time you buy your vehicle, and in some cases, the price may be negotiable. However, dealership coverage is typically 100–250% more expensive than other options, and if the cost is financed, you end up paying interest on top of the premium. Additionally, buyers may face high-pressure sales tactics when considering this coverage.
Lenders and Finance Companies
Credit unions and other lenders or finance companies often offer gap insurance at a lower cost, and in some cases, coverage may be included directly in your loan paperwork for convenience. However, these options typically come with flat fees ranging from $400 to $700 and are generally less flexible compared to other providers.
Standalone Providers
Standalone providers offer gap insurance at a middle-ground price, typically as a one-time payment rather than an ongoing premium. However, they come with some drawbacks, including limited availability and the need to handle a separate claims process outside of your regular auto insurance.
Real-World Cost Examples
Gap insurance costs can vary dramatically depending on the vehicle, loan terms, and where you purchase it. Here are some real-world examples to illustrate the potential savings:
Budget Buyer
A 2024 Honda Civic purchased with a 10% down payment on a 60-month loan could get gap insurance through Progressive for just $144 total over the life of the loan. The same coverage offered by the dealership would cost $673, resulting in a savings of $529.
Luxury Vehicle
For a 2024 BMW X5 financed with a 5% down payment on a 72-month loan, gap insurance through Allstate costs $200, whereas the dealership charges $1,050. Choosing the insurer over the dealer saves the buyer $850, making it an especially valuable investment for high-value vehicles.
Used Vehicle
A 2022 Toyota RAV4 with a 15% down payment on a 60-month loan can be covered by State Farm for $144, compared to $755 at the dealership. This results in a savings of $611, showing that even used vehicles benefit from shopping around for gap coverage.
First-Time Buyer
A 19-year-old purchasing a 2024 Nissan Sentra with 0% down on a 72-month loan could pay $84 per year for gap insurance through an insurer, while the dealership charges $550 for the same coverage. This creates a savings of $466, demonstrating that younger drivers with smaller down payments can save significantly by avoiding dealer markups.
These examples highlight the importance of comparing quotes from insurers, credit unions, and banks rather than assuming the dealership’s price is fair. In most cases, buying gap insurance through your own provider can save hundreds—and sometimes over a thousand dollars—while providing identical protection.
How Much Can Gap Insurance Save You?
Gap insurance can save you a significant amount of money in the event your vehicle is totaled or stolen. On average, gap insurance claims range from $5,000 to $10,000, meaning without coverage, you would have to pay that amount out of pocket to settle your auto loan.
For example, consider a $35,000 car with a loan balance of $29,500 and an actual cash value (ACV) of $23,000. In this case, gap insurance would cover the difference between the ACV and what you still owe on your loan, less your deductible. If the gap insurance cost is only $60 over three years, your potential savings would be $6,440—a small investment compared to the financial protection it provides.
Even relatively small annual premiums, typically $20–$100, can save you thousands in a worst-case scenario. Beyond the financial benefits, gap insurance offers peace of mind, knowing that you won’t be left paying off a loan for a car you no longer have. It’s particularly valuable for new vehicles, leases, or loans with minimal down payments, where depreciation can quickly outpace your loan balance.
This coverage ensures that a total loss doesn’t become a long-term financial burden, making it a smart addition to many auto insurance policies.
When You Need Gap Insurance
You should strongly consider gap insurance if you made a small down payment, have a high loan-to-value ratio, purchased a new or fast-depreciating vehicle, or are leasing your car. These situations increase the risk that your loan balance will exceed the vehicle’s actual cash value, especially in the first few years when depreciation is steep. Gap insurance is particularly important for leases, as many lease agreements require it due to the higher likelihood of a payoff shortfall after a total loss.
On the other hand, you likely don’t need gap insurance if you paid 20% or more as a down payment, have positive equity in your vehicle, have already paid off more than half of your loan, or own an older vehicle that has largely finished depreciating. In these cases, the difference between what you owe and what the car is worth is minimal or nonexistent, making gap coverage unnecessary.
You should consider dropping gap insurance once your loan balance falls below your vehicle’s market value, which typically happens after about 2–4 years of regular payments, depending on loan terms and depreciation. To check your status, periodically compare your remaining loan balance with your car’s current value using reliable valuation tools such as Kelley Blue Book (KBB.com), Edmunds.com, or NADA Guides. This review helps ensure you keep gap insurance only for as long as it actually provides financial protection.
How to Get the Cheapest Gap Insurance
To get the cheapest gap insurance, start by buying it from your auto insurer, as this option is often 80–90% cheaper than dealership coverage. If you’re considering dealer gap insurance, negotiate the price and use competitor quotes as leverage, and try to purchase coverage within 30 days of buying the vehicle, when more options are usually available. Take advantage of bundle discounts, maintain a clean driving record, and avoid over-insuring by choosing capped coverage that matches your actual risk. Improving your credit score and making a larger down payment can also reduce or eliminate the need for gap insurance altogether. Watch for red flags such as high-pressure sales tactics, unclear refund policies, prices above $700, or claims that gap insurance is “required,” which are often signs you should walk away.
Gap Insurance vs. Alternative Coverage
| Coverage Option | What It Covers | Cost Comparison | Limitations / Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gap Insurance | Pays the difference between your loan balance and the vehicle’s actual cash value (ACV) after a total loss | Generally affordable, especially through auto insurers | Coverage ends once the loan balance is lower than the vehicle value |
| Loan/Lease Payoff | Covers up to 25% of ACV beyond your car’s value | Cheaper than full gap insurance | Limited coverage may not fully pay off the loan |
| New Car Replacement | Pays for a brand-new car if yours is totaled | Typically 30–50% more expensive | Often limited to newer vehicles and the first few model years |
| Car Replacement Assistance (USAA) | Pays 20% above ACV toward a replacement vehicle | Moderately priced | Only available to eligible USAA members |
| Payoff Protector (State Farm) | Helps pay off the remaining loan balance | Cost varies by policy | Limited to State Farm Bank loans |
| Larger Down Payment | Reduces or eliminates negative equity | No insurance cost | Requires more upfront cash, but can remove the need for gap insurance entirely |
How to Buy Gap Insurance: Step-by-Step
Buying gap insurance doesn’t have to be complicated. Follow these steps to make sure you get the right coverage at the right price—and avoid paying for protection you don’t actually need.
Determine Whether You Need Gap Insurance
Start by evaluating your loan-to-value (LTV) ratio, which compares how much you still owe on your auto loan to your car’s current market value. You’re more likely to need gap insurance if you made a small or no down payment (typically under 20%), financed the vehicle for 60 months or longer, purchased a car that depreciates quickly—such as a new vehicle—or rolled negative equity from a previous loan into your new one. If your loan balance is higher than the car’s actual cash value (ACV), gap insurance can protect you from paying thousands of dollars out of pocket after a total loss.
Get Quotes From at Least 3–5 Providers
Prices for gap insurance can vary widely, so shopping around is essential to find the best value. Request quotes from your current auto insurance company, one or two other major insurers, a credit union or bank, and the dealership as a point of comparison rather than a default choice. Be sure to ask for written quotes so you can accurately compare coverage details, limits, and total costs side by side before making a decision.
Compare All Available Options
Don’t assume the dealer’s offer is the best option, as pricing and coverage can vary significantly. In many cases, auto insurers provide the lowest annual cost when gap coverage is added directly to your existing policy, while credit unions may offer gap insurance for a reasonable one-time fee bundled with your loan. Dealerships often charge the most, especially when the cost is rolled into the loan and accrues interest over time. Look beyond price alone and compare how much each option covers, along with the length and limits of the coverage.
Review the Terms Carefully
Before purchasing gap insurance, carefully read the fine print and review all policy terms in detail. Pay close attention to coverage limits, as some policies only pay up to 125%–150% of the vehicle’s actual cash value, and check whether the policy covers your auto insurance deductible or requires you to pay it out of pocket. Look for exclusions such as late loan payments, extended warranties, or rolled-in fees that may not be covered, and review eligibility rules like maximum vehicle age or mileage. A cheaper policy isn’t a good deal if it leaves significant gaps in coverage when you need it most.
Purchase and Confirm the Start Date
Once you’ve chosen the best gap insurance option, add the coverage to your auto insurance policy or include it with your loan, depending on where you’re purchasing it. Make sure the effective date aligns with your loan start date so there’s no gap in protection, and request written confirmation or a policy declaration page for your records. Never assume coverage is active until you’ve verified all details in writing, as even small timing errors can leave you temporarily uninsured.
Document Everything and Monitor Your Loan
Keep copies of your gap insurance policy, loan agreement, and all vehicle purchase documents in one secure place so they’re easy to access if you ever need to file a claim or review your coverage. Over time, regularly compare your remaining loan balance with your vehicle’s current market value, since depreciation slows and loan balances decrease as you make payments. Once you owe less than the car is worth, gap insurance is no longer necessary, and canceling it at that point can help you avoid paying for coverage you no longer need.
Final Thoughts
How much is gap insurance? $20-$100/year through insurers vs. $400-$700+ at dealerships. The difference is dramatic, often saving 80–90%.
For most financed vehicles, especially with small down payments, gap insurance is a must. Calculate your loan balance vs. vehicle value and buy from your insurance company to avoid overpaying. A small annual premium today could save thousands tomorrow if your car is totaled.
FAQs
-
How much does gap insurance cost monthly?
$2–$8 through insurers; $8–$12 financed at dealerships.
2. Is gap insurance worth it?
Yes, if your loan exceeds your car’s value, it covers thousands in losses.
3. Can I buy gap insurance after purchase?
Yes, usually within 30–90 days; vehicle must meet age/mileage requirements.
4. Can I cancel gap insurance?
Yes, prorated refunds are common; insurance company policies are easier to cancel.
5. Do I need full coverage for gap insurance?
Yes, insurers require comprehensive and collision coverage.
